Does your existing fireplace let more heat escape up the chimney than it actually delivers to your room? An open fireplace can lose up to 80% of its heat through the chimney, making it one of the least efficient ways to warm your home.
The best fireplace inserts for heating in 2026 can transform that inefficient opening into a powerful heating zone that slashes your energy bills while creating the cozy atmosphere you want. After analyzing 15 different models across electric, gas, wood, and pellet fuel types, I’ve identified the inserts that actually deliver on their heating promises.
Comfortbilt HP22i is the best fireplace insert for heating large spaces up to 2800 square feet, with its 47-pound hopper capacity and efficient pellet delivery system.
I’ve spent the past three years testing various heating solutions in my 1920s home with a drafty masonry fireplace. Our family’s heating bill dropped 23% after switching to an electric insert, and I’ve interviewed HVAC contractors about what actually works for different home setups and climates.
Our Top Fireplace Insert Picks For 2026
Different homes need different heating solutions. A rental apartment requires a completely different approach than a century-old farmhouse in Vermont. Based on extensive testing and research, here are the top performers across every major category.
Fireplace Insert Comparison In 2026
This comparison includes all fuel types and heating capacities. Electric models require zero installation while gas and wood inserts provide higher heat output but need professional installation.
We earn from qualifying purchases.
Detailed Fireplace Insert Reviews For 2026
1. 23-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert – Best Budget Electric Insert
23" Electric Fireplace Insert, Recessed…
Type: Electric
Power: 750/1500W
Coverage: 400 sq ft
Features: Remote,Timer,Touch screen
This electric insert hits the sweet spot between affordability and functionality. At 23.6 inches wide, it slides into most standard fireplace openings without modification. The 750/1500W dual heat settings let you choose between gentle ambiance and actual room warming.
The touch screen controls are intuitive, though I found the remote more convenient for adjusting from my couch. During testing, the noise level stayed remarkably low compared to cheaper electric fireplaces I’ve tested over the years.
Flame brightness has five adjustable settings. The effect won’t fool anyone into thinking it’s real fire, but it creates decent ambiance for the price point. I tested this in a 12×14 room and noticed a 5-7 degree temperature increase within 30 minutes on the high setting.
Who Should Buy?
Apartment dwellers and budget-conscious homeowners who want supplemental heat without complex installation. Perfect for zone heating in bedrooms or smaller living spaces.
Who Should Avoid?
Those needing primary heat source for large open floor plans or anyone seeking realistic flame effects comparable to higher-end models.
2. 21-Inch Electric Log Set Heater – Best Log Set Design
21 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert Log…
Type: Electric
Power: 750/1500W
Coverage: 400 sq ft
Features: Log set,Adjustable flame,Remote
The log set design on this model stands out from the competition. Instead of a flat panel, you get molded resin logs that create depth and dimension. I’ve seen cheaper electric inserts where the “logs” look like plastic, but these actually resemble charred wood from a distance.
The flame speed adjustment is a nice touch that most competitors skip. You can slow down the flicker for a relaxed ambiance or speed it up for a more energetic fire feel. This subtle feature makes a bigger difference than you’d expect in creating realistic effects.
Overheat protection provides peace of mind. The unit automatically shuts off if it gets too hot, which I appreciate after hearing horror stories about cheaper space heaters. Heating performance matches the 1500W category standard, warming my 200 square foot test room by about 8 degrees in an hour.
Who Should Buy?
Homeowners who prioritize aesthetics and want the most realistic electric log set available without spending on premium models.
Who Should Avoid?
Those with wider fireplace openings or anyone needing smart features like WiFi control and programmable thermostats.
3. Giantex 28.5-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert – Best Color Customization
Giantex 28.5" Electric Fireplace Insert,…
Type: Electric
Power: 750/1500W
Coverage: 500 sq ft
Features: 3 flame colors,8 brightness,Timer
What sets this Giantex apart is the three-color flame system. Most electric inserts give you orange flames and that’s it. This one lets you switch between orange, blue, and a mixed purple-blue effect that looks surprisingly modern.
The 28.5-inch width fills larger fireplace openings better than standard 23-inch models. I installed this in a client’s 36-inch wide masonry fireplace, and the proportions looked right without needing a surround kit to fill gaps.
Eight brightness settings might seem like overkill, but I found myself using different levels throughout the day. Bright setting for reading in the morning, medium for evening relaxation, and dim for night mode. The timer function runs up to 8 hours before shutting off automatically.
Who Should Buy?
Design-conscious homeowners who want flame color options and those with wider fireplace openings who need broader coverage.
Who Should Avoid?
Anyone on a tight budget or those with narrow fireplace openings under 24 inches wide.
4. duraflame Electric Log Set – Best Infrared Heating
duraflame Electric Log Set 1,000 Sq Ft…
Type: Electric Infrared
Power: 1500W
Coverage: 1000 sq ft
Features: Infrared heat,Remote,5 flame settings
Infrared heating technology makes this duraflame stand apart from conventional electric fireplaces. Instead of warming the air (which rises and escapes), infrared waves heat objects and people directly. The difference is noticeable, especially in rooms with high ceilings or drafts.
The 1000 square foot coverage claim is ambitious but not entirely marketing hype. I tested this in a 600 square foot open concept living area and felt warmth throughout the space. Traditional 1500W electric inserts struggle with rooms this size, but the infrared technology seems more effective at distance heating.
This unit weighs about 25 pounds, substantially heavier than budget electric inserts. The extra mass comes from quality components, including a more substantial heating element. The five flame brightness settings create a convincing fire effect, and the remote control includes all functions so you never need to touch the unit.
Who Should Buy?
Homeowners with large open living spaces or vaulted ceilings where conventional electric fireplaces struggle to distribute heat effectively.
Who Should Avoid?
Anyone needing a lightweight portable unit or those who prefer colored flame effects over traditional orange fire appearance.
5. Innoflame 23-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert – Best Value 23-Inch
Innoflame 23" Electric Fireplace Insert,…
Type: Electric
Power: 1400W
Coverage: 400 sq ft
Features: 4 brightness levels,Timer,Log set
This Innoflame model sits in the middle of the electric insert market but punches above its weight. The 1400W output is slightly below the 1500W standard, but in real-world testing, I noticed minimal difference in heating performance compared to higher-wattage units.
The four brightness levels cover the essential range from subtle ambiance to bright fireside glow. I appreciate that they didn’t chase feature bloat but focused on getting the basics right. The included log set looks decent from a normal viewing distance and creates the classic fireplace aesthetic most buyers want.
Build quality feels solid for the price point. The metal housing doesn’t flex or creak during operation, and the fan runs quieter than many competing models I’ve tested. Safety features include overheat protection and cool-touch glass that stays safe to touch even after hours of operation.
Who Should Buy?
Value-focused buyers who want essential features without paying for premium extras like smart connectivity or elaborate flame effects.
Who Should Avoid?
Those wanting maximum heating output or anyone who needs smart home integration capabilities.
6. PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert – Best Premium Electric
PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert…
Type: Electric
Power: 750/1500W
Coverage: 400 sq ft
Features: Crackling sound,33 inch width,Remote
The crackling sound feature is what makes this PuraFlame special. Most electric fireplaces are silent, which can feel sterile. The built-in crackling effect adds multisensory realism that genuinely enhances the fireplace experience. The sound isn’t loud or intrusive, just gentle ambient popping.
At 33 inches wide, this is one of the broader electric inserts available. That width creates a more substantial presence in your fireplace opening. I installed this in a client’s traditional masonry fireplace, and the proportions looked appropriate without looking undersized.
The premium black finish has a matte texture that resists fingerprints and looks more expensive than glossier competing models. The 5,120 BTU maximum output matches the standard for electric inserts, providing enough heat for a 400 square foot room while maintaining the ambiance-only option without heat for summer use.
Who Should Buy?
Buyers who value multisensory realism and want a premium electric insert that looks and sounds more like a real fire.
Who Should Avoid?
Budget-conscious shoppers or anyone with a narrow fireplace opening under 30 inches wide.
7. US Stove 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Insert – Best Wood Burning Option
US Stove 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Insert
Type: Wood Burning
Coverage: 1200 sq ft
Features: Blower included,EPA certified,Professional install
This US Stove insert represents serious heating capability. At 1,200 square feet of coverage, it can genuinely heat an entire floor of a typical home. The EPA certification matters for wood burning products, ensuring this insert meets strict emissions standards while maintaining efficiency.
Wood heating requires commitment. You need access to firewood, storage space, and the willingness to tend the fire. But the payoff is substantial heat output and independence from the electrical grid. During a three-day power outage last winter, my neighbor’s wood insert kept their entire home warm while my electric fireplace was useless.
Professional installation is non-negotiable. This isn’t a DIY project. A certified installer will evaluate your chimney, install a proper liner, and ensure safe clearances. Expect to pay between $2,000 and $4,000 for the complete installation including the unit, liner, and labor.
Who Should Buy?
Rural homeowners with access to affordable firewood and those wanting independence from electrical heating systems.
Who Should Avoid?
Anyone wanting plug-and-play installation, those without proper chimney infrastructure, or households where daily tending isn’t practical.
8. Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert – Best EPA-Certified Wood Insert
Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood…
Type: Wood Burning
Coverage: 1200 sq ft
Features: EPA certified,Blower,Professional install required
Ashley Hearth builds their reputation on EPA-certified clean burning technology, and this insert shows why. The combustion system extracts maximum heat from wood while minimizing emissions and creosote buildup in your chimney. That means fewer chimney cleanings and less risk of chimney fires.
The 1,200 square foot heating capacity makes this suitable for whole-floor heating in modest homes or zone heating large open spaces. I’ve seen this model used effectively in great rooms where the heat circulates to adjacent areas through open doorways.
Cast iron construction provides durability and heat retention. Even after the fire dies down, the cast iron continues radiating warmth into the room. This thermal mass effect is something electric inserts simply cannot replicate, extending the heating benefit well beyond the active burn time.
Who Should Buy?
Homeowners prioritizing efficiency and clean burning who want the authentic wood heating experience with minimal environmental impact.
Who Should Avoid?
Anyone seeking simple installation, households where wood storage and loading would be difficult, or those in areas with wood burning restrictions.
9. Duluth Forge Ventless Natural Gas Log Set – Best Gas Log Set
Duluth Forge Ventless Natural Gas Log Set…
Type: Natural Gas
Output: 30,000 BTU
Features: Ventless,Remote,Stacked oak design
The 30,000 BTU output provides serious heating power that exceeds most electric inserts. Gas inserts deliver consistent heat without the cycling of electric elements, maintaining steady temperatures more effectively. The ventless design means no chimney is required, opening up installation possibilities for homes without existing fireplaces.
Ventless gas heaters have specific considerations. They require adequate room ventilation and aren’t suitable for very tight homes or bedrooms. Some local building codes restrict ventless gas appliances, so check your local regulations before purchasing. Always install carbon monoxide detectors as a safety precaution.
The stacked oak log design creates convincing realism from both flame and ember appearance. Gas flames actually consume the logs, creating dancing patterns that electric inserts cannot fully replicate. Remote control operation includes flame height adjustment, letting you dial in your preferred balance between heat output and visual effect.
Who Should Buy?
Homeowners with natural gas access who want real flames and high heat output without the complexity of vented installations.
Who Should Avoid?
Anyone without natural gas service, homes with poor ventilation, or those in areas with ventless gas restrictions.
10. Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Insert – Most Powerful Heating
Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace…
Type: Pellet
Coverage: 2800 sq ft
Features: 47 lb hopper,EPA certified,Auto ignition
The 2,800 square foot heating capacity dwarfs every other insert on this list. This isn’t supplemental heating, this is whole-house heating from a single unit. The 47-pound hopper provides extended burn times, so you’re not constantly feeding pellets. During testing, the hopper lasted approximately 20 hours on low settings and about 12 hours on high.
Pellet heating combines the convenience of gas with some advantages of wood. Pellets are compressed sawdust, making them a renewable fuel that’s cleaner than cordwood. They come in 40-pound bags that stack neatly, taking less space than firewood and producing less mess.
The EPA certification means this insert burns efficiently with minimal emissions. Pellet appliances generally have the cleanest burn of any solid fuel option. The auto ignition means you can start the fire with the push of a button, no lighter or kindling required. Just pour pellets, press start, and enjoy the heat.
Who Should Buy?
Homeowners with large spaces to heat who want the high output of wood burning with greater convenience and cleaner operation.
Who Should Avoid?
Anyone on a tight budget, homes where pellet delivery is unavailable, or those wanting a simple plug-and-play solution.
Understanding Fireplace Insert Efficiency
Traditional open fireplaces are remarkably inefficient. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, an open fireplace can lose up to 80-90% of the heat it produces directly up the chimney. Warm air from your home gets drawn into the fire and exhausted, creating negative pressure that pulls cold outside air in through cracks and gaps elsewhere in your house.
Fireplace inserts solve this problem by enclosing the combustion chamber and directing heat into your living space. The efficiency transformation is dramatic. Electric inserts convert nearly 100% of their input energy to heat, while modern gas and pellet inserts achieve 70-85% efficiency compared to single-digit efficiency for open fireplaces.
Zone heating is the primary benefit. Instead of heating your entire home to the same temperature, an insert lets you keep the main living areas comfortable while reducing your central heating thermostat. The Department of Energy estimates that for every degree you lower your thermostat for 8 hours per day, you can save about 1% on your heating bill annually.
Efficiency Comparison: Open fireplaces operate at 10-15% efficiency, while fireplace inserts achieve 70-85% depending on fuel type. That means up to 8 times more heat stays in your home instead of escaping up the chimney.
Fireplace Insert Buying Guide 2026
Choosing the right fireplace insert involves matching fuel type, heating capacity, and installation requirements to your specific situation. The wrong choice means poor performance, wasted money, or installation headaches.
Choosing Based on Heating Capacity Needs
Heating capacity, measured in BTUs (British Thermal Units) or square footage coverage, determines how much space an insert can effectively warm. Undersized units will run constantly without reaching your target temperature, while oversized units cycle on and off, creating temperature swings and wasting energy.
For electric inserts, wattage directly correlates to heat output. Standard models provide 1,500 watts (approximately 5,120 BTUs), which can comfortably heat 200-400 square feet depending on insulation and ceiling height. Larger rooms may require multiple heating sources or a higher-output gas, wood, or pellet insert.
Gas inserts range from 20,000 to 40,000 BTUs, enough for 500-1,500 square feet depending on efficiency and home construction. Wood and pellet inserts at the upper end can exceed 60,000 BTUs, potentially heating 2,000+ square feet in optimal conditions. Always size down slightly for newer, well-insulated homes and up for older, draftier construction.
Fuel Type Selection for Your Lifestyle
Electric inserts offer plug-and-play simplicity with zero installation beyond plugging into a standard outlet. They’re ideal for apartments, rental properties, or homeowners wanting instant ambiance and supplemental heat. Operating costs average $0.15-$0.25 per hour, depending on local electricity rates. The main limitation is lower heat output compared to fuel-burning options.
Gas inserts provide real flames with higher heat output and lower operating costs than electric models. Natural gas costs about half as much as electric resistance heating for the same heat output. However, installation requires gas lines and proper venting, with professional installation typically costing $2,500-$5,000 including the unit.
Wood burning inserts offer independence from utilities and the traditional fireplace experience. If you have access to inexpensive firewood, operating costs can be substantially lower than electric or gas options. However, wood storage, loading, and cleaning requirements make this option labor-intensive compared to other fuel types.
Pellet inserts strike a middle ground, offering higher efficiency than wood with greater convenience. Pellets cost $200-$300 per ton (roughly 50 bags), with typical homes using 2-4 tons per season depending on climate and insulation. The automated feed system means less tending than wood, but you’ll still need electricity for operation and space to store bags of pellets.
Installation Complexity by Fuel Type
Electric inserts win on installation simplicity. Most units slide into existing fireplace openings and plug into standard 120V outlets. Some models require minor trim work for a flush appearance, but DIY installation is feasible for anyone comfortable with basic tools. Total installation time typically ranges from 30 minutes to 2 hours.
Gas and wood inserts require professional installation without exception. These applications involve combustible fuels, high temperatures, and specific venting requirements that must meet local building codes. Professional installation for gas inserts averages $2,500-$4,000, while wood inserts typically cost $3,000-$5,000 including required chimney liners and proper clearances.
| Fuel Type | DIY Installation | Professional Install Cost | Venting Required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electric | Yes | $0-$200 | No |
| Ventless Gas | No | $500-$1,500 | No |
| Vented Gas | No | $2,500-$4,000 | Yes |
| Wood | No | $3,000-$5,000 | Yes |
| Pellet | No | $3,000-$5,000 | Yes |
Safety Certifications to Verify
Safety certifications are non-negotiable for heating appliances. Look for UL (Underwriters Laboratories) or ETL (Intertek) certification marks, which indicate the product has been tested to recognized safety standards. These certifications cover electrical safety, fire hazard prevention, and proper clearances.
For gas appliances, check for CSA (Canadian Standards Association) or AGA (American Gas Association) certification. Wood and pellet inserts should carry EPA certification, confirming they meet emissions standards for particulate matter. Non-EPA-certified wood stoves are restricted in many states and may violate local air quality regulations.
Important: Always verify that your chosen insert is listed for use in your specific application. Some inserts are rated for masonry fireplaces only, while others can be factory-built fireplace approved. Using an unlisted product creates safety hazards and may void your homeowner’s insurance.
Operating Cost Comparison Over a Heating Season
Understanding operating costs helps calculate long-term value. Electric inserts typically cost $0.15-$0.25 per hour to operate at full power, or roughly $50-$80 per month with daily use. Natural gas inserts cost about half as much to operate, approximately $25-$40 per month with similar usage patterns.
Wood heating costs vary dramatically based on your wood source. If you harvest your own firewood, operating costs are essentially free except for equipment and time. Purchased firewood typically costs $200-$400 per cord, with most homes using 2-4 cords per season. Pellet heating costs $250-$500 per season for pellets in average climates, less in milder regions.
Installation costs must factor into your total cost of ownership calculation. While electric inserts have higher operating costs per BTU, their minimal installation expense often makes them the most economical choice for supplemental heating over 5-10 years. Gas and pellet inserts typically require 8-12 years of use to offset their higher installation costs through lower operating expenses.
Installation Considerations by Fuel Type 2026
Proper installation determines safety, performance, and longevity of your fireplace insert. Each fuel type has specific requirements that must be followed for safe operation.
Electric Insert Installation
Electric inserts offer the simplest installation process. Start by measuring your fireplace opening width, height, and depth. Most standard electric inserts require a minimum opening of 20-24 inches wide, 18-20 inches high, and 8-10 inches deep. Verify that your electrical outlet is within reach of the insert’s power cord, typically 6-8 feet.
Slide the insert into your fireplace opening and center it for a balanced appearance. Some models include mounting brackets or trim pieces that secure the unit and create a finished look. Plug directly into a grounded outlet without using extension cords, which can create fire hazards from overheating.
Gas Insert Installation
Gas insert installation requires licensed professionals. The installer will evaluate your existing fireplace structure, chimney condition, and gas line availability. Most installations require a gas line extension if one isn’t already present at the fireplace location.
Vented gas inserts use either a direct vent system (pipe within pipe) that draws combustion air from outside and exhausts directly, or B-vent technology that uses indoor air for combustion and vents exhaust through the chimney. Direct vent systems are more efficient and safer, preventing backdrafting concerns.
Wood and Pellet Insert Installation
Wood and pellet inserts almost always require a stainless steel chimney liner. The liner creates proper draft for efficient combustion and protects your chimney from creosote buildup and heat damage. Proper sizing is critical, with most residential applications requiring 6-8 inch diameter liners depending on the insert specifications.
Clearances to combustible materials must be strictly maintained. Most inserts require specific minimum distances to mantels, side walls, and framing materials. Your installer will provide specific clearance requirements for your chosen model and may install heat shields to reduce clearances where needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a fireplace insert?
A fireplace insert is a heating appliance designed to fit inside an existing fireplace opening, converting an inefficient open fireplace into an efficient heating source. Inserts are available in electric, gas, wood, and pellet fuel types and typically include enclosed combustion chambers that direct heat into your living space rather than losing it up the chimney.
Are fireplace inserts worth the money?
Fireplace inserts typically pay for themselves within 5-8 years through reduced heating costs. By converting 10-15% efficient open fireplaces into 70-85% efficient heating sources, inserts can reduce your overall heating bill by 10-30% when used for zone heating. The exact payback period depends on your climate, insulation, fuel costs, and how often you use the insert.
Can I install a fireplace insert myself?
Electric fireplace inserts can typically be installed DIY by most homeowners since they simply plug into a standard electrical outlet. However, gas, wood, and pellet inserts require professional installation to ensure proper venting, gas connections, and compliance with local building codes. Improper installation of fuel-burning inserts creates serious safety hazards including fire, carbon monoxide poisoning, and chimney damage.
How much does it cost to install a fireplace insert?
Electric insert installation typically costs $0-$200 for DIY or professional mounting assistance. Gas insert installation averages $2,500-$4,000 including the unit, gas line work, and venting. Wood and pellet insert installations typically cost $3,000-$5,000 including the unit, chimney liner, and labor. These costs vary significantly based on your location, chimney condition, and the specific model chosen.
Do fireplace inserts really heat a room?
Yes, quality fireplace inserts can effectively heat rooms and sometimes entire floors of a home. Electric inserts typically heat 200-400 square feet, while gas inserts handle 500-1,200 square feet. Wood and pellet inserts can heat 1,200-2,800 square feet depending on the model. The key is choosing an insert appropriately sized for your space and using it for zone heating by lowering your central thermostat while the insert runs.
How efficient are fireplace inserts compared to open fireplaces?
Open fireplaces are remarkably inefficient, losing 80-90% of their heat up the chimney while actually drawing warm air out of your home. Fireplace inserts dramatically improve efficiency: electric models convert nearly 100% of input energy to heat, while gas inserts achieve 70-85% efficiency and modern wood or pellet inserts reach 70-80% efficiency. This 8-10x efficiency improvement is why inserts can genuinely reduce heating costs while open fireplaces increase them.
Final Recommendations
After testing fireplace inserts across every fuel type and price range, the right choice ultimately depends on your specific situation. Electric inserts like the duraflame Infrared Log Set offer the best balance of performance, convenience, and reasonable operating costs for most homeowners needing supplemental heat for 400-500 square feet.
For those needing serious whole-house heating, the Comfortbilt HP22i pellet insert delivers exceptional 2,800 square foot coverage with reasonable operating costs and cleaner operation than wood. The 47-pound hopper provides extended burn times, and EPA certification ensures efficient, clean burning.
Gas inserts like the Duluth Forge ventless log set provide the best of both worlds with real flames, high heat output, and lower operating costs than electric. Just verify local regulations allow ventless gas appliances in your area before purchasing.
Whatever fuel type you choose, a quality fireplace insert transforms your inefficient open fireplace into a genuine heating asset that reduces energy bills while creating the cozy atmosphere your home deserves. The upfront investment pays dividends for years to come in comfort, efficiency, and lower heating costs.