Hey there, fellow Dreamlight Valley enthusiast! If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably found yourself staring at the “Cook a fairly fancy dessert” duty in the Witchful Thinking Star Path and wondering, “What on earth does that even mean?” Don’t worry—I’ve been there too, and I’m here to break it all down for you in the most straightforward way possible.
When I first encountered this task during the Witchful Thinking Star Path event, I’ll admit I was a bit confused. I tried making what I thought were fancy desserts, only to realize they weren’t counting toward my progress. After some trial and error (and a lot of research), I finally figured it out, and now I’m sharing everything I’ve learned so you can complete this duty with ease and earn those precious Bubbling Brew Tokens!
What Exactly Is a “Fairly Fancy Dessert”?
Let’s get right to the point—because I know you’re eager to get cooking! A “fairly fancy dessert” in Disney Dreamlight Valley refers to any four-star or better dessert recipe. That means you’re looking at recipes that require four or five ingredients to create.
Now, I should mention that this definition can sometimes change between different Star Path events. For example, during the Retro Roadtrip event, “fairly fancy” specifically meant five-star desserts only. But for the current Witchful Thinking Star Path (which runs from October 1 to December 7, 2026), both four-star and five-star desserts count toward this duty.
The task requires you to cook three fairly fancy desserts to complete it, and you’ll earn 20 Bubbling Brew Tokens for your efforts—that’s the maximum reward you can get from any single duty, making this one definitely worth prioritizing!
The Witchful Thinking Star Path Context
Before we dive into the recipes, let me give you some context about why this matters. The Witchful Thinking Star Path is all about embracing that magical, autumnal witchy vibe. You’re choosing between being a poised potion maker or someone woodsy and wild (or maybe both, like me!).
When I’m working through these Star Path duties, I always try to focus on the ones that give me the most bang for my buck, and the “cook a fairly fancy dessert” duty is definitely one of those. With 20 tokens up for grabs, it’s a solid investment of your time and ingredients.
Complete List of 4-Star Fairly Fancy Desserts
Alright, here’s the good stuff! I’ve compiled a comprehensive list of all the four-star dessert recipes that count as “fairly fancy desserts.” I’ve organized them by where you can find them—some are available in the base Dreamlight Valley, while others require the Eternity Isle or Storybook Vale expansions.
Base Dreamlight Valley 4-Star Desserts
| Dessert Name | Ingredients Required |
|---|---|
| Banana Ice Cream | Slush Ice, Banana, Milk, Sugarcane |
| Beignets | Canola, Wheat, Egg, Sugarcane |
| Carrot Cake | Carrot, Wheat, Egg, Sugarcane |
| Cheesecake | Cheese, Wheat, Sugarcane, Any Fruit |
| Cheshire Cat Tail | Cocoa Bean, Egg, Wheat, Sugarcane |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies | Cocoa Bean, Wheat, Sugarcane, Butter |
| Chocolate Ice Cream | Cocoa Bean, Sugarcane, Slush Ice, Milk |
| Chocolate Waffles | Cocoa Bean, Wheat, Egg, Milk |
| Coconut Cake | Coconut, Wheat, Egg, Sugarcane |
| Coconut Ice Cream | Coconut, Sugarcane, Slush Ice, Milk |
| Crepe | Wheat, Milk, Egg, Vanilla |
| Fruitcake | Wheat, Any Fruit, Any Fruit, Any Fruit |
| Jam Waffles | Any Fruit, Wheat, Egg, Milk |
| Joyful Meal | Wheat, Blueberry, Raspberries, Banana |
| Meringue Pie | Lemon, Butter, Wheat, Egg |
| Mint Chocolate | Mint, Cocoa Bean, Sugarcane, Butter |
| Peanut Butter Waffles | Peanuts, Wheat, Egg, Milk |
| Red Fruit Sorbet | Raspberry, Gooseberry, Sugarcane, Slush Ice |
| Roasted Marshmallows | Pink Marshmallow x2, Blue Marshmallow x2 |
| Spring Mimosa Eggs | Spring V-EGG-etable, Wild Spring Egg, Egg-cellent Fruit, Basil |
| S’mores | Pink Marshmallow, Blue Marshmallow, Wheat x2 |
| Sugar Kart Seat | Sugar Rush Seat Fudge, Wheat, Milk, Butter |
| Sugar Kart Tail | Sugar Rush Tail Fudge, Wheat, Sugarcane, Butter |
| Sugar Kart Wheel | Sugar Rush Wheel Fudge, Wheat, Sugarcane, Egg |
| Tropical Pop | Slush Ice, Coconut, Sugarcane, Any Fruit |
| Vanilla Ice Cream | Slush Ice, Milk, Sugarcane, Vanilla |
| Waffles | Wheat, Milk, Egg, Any Sweet |
| Wonderland Cookies | Butter, Vanilla, Sugarcane, Wheat |
| Yule Log | Wheat, Vanilla, Cocoa Beans, Cherries |
Eternity Isle 4-Star Desserts
| Dessert Name | Ingredients Required |
|---|---|
| Cannoli | Wheat, Egg, Cheese, Vanilla |
| Cinnamon Donut | Wheat, Egg, Cinnamon, Any Sweet |
| Cupcakes | Wheat, Egg, Cherry, Agave |
| Danish | Wheat, Butter, Any Fruit, Any Fruit |
| Kanelbulle | Wheat, Butter, Egg, Cinnamon |
| Kouign-Amann | Wheat, Butter x2, Agave |
| Makrout | Wheat, Canola, Dates, Cinnamon |
| Mooncake | Wheat, Canola, Bean, Agave |
| Nestling Crepe | Wheat, Egg, Milk, Nestling Pear |
| Pasteis de Nata | Corn, Egg, Milk, Vanilla |
| Sugar-Free Fruit Explosion Muffin | Wheat, Any Fruit, Any Fruit, Agave |
Storybook Vale 4-Star Desserts
| Dessert Name | Ingredients Required |
|---|---|
| Cinnamon Cookies | Wheat, Yogurt, Cinnamon, Any Sweet |
| Cinnamon Cake | Wheat, Shovel Bird Egg, Yogurt, Cinnamon |
| Lightning Cake | Wheat, Shovel Bird Egg, Yogurt, Lightning Spice |
| Lightning Cookies | Wheat, Yogurt, Lightning Spice, Any Sweet |
| Nutmeg Cake | Wheat, Shovel Bird Egg, Yogurt, Nutmeg |
| Nutmeg Cookies | Wheat, Yogurt, Nutmeg, Any Sweet |
| Strawberry Rhubarb Pie | Wheat, Yogurt, Rhubarb, Spiral Strawberry |
Best 5-Star Desserts for Maximum Benefits
Now, if you really want to go all out (and I mean, why not?), you can also cook five-star desserts for this duty. These not only count toward your “fairly fancy dessert” requirement but also restore more energy and sell for more coins. Here are some of the best five-star desserts I’ve found:
Top 5-Star Desserts by Energy Restoration
| Dessert Name | Energy Restored | Selling Price | Ingredients Required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Red Velvet | 2,458+ | 783 Coins | Wheat, Cheese, Eggs, Cocoa Bean, Vanilla |
| Spaceship Earth Cupcake | 2,400+ | 772 Coins | Milk, Wheat, Butter, Sugarcane, Coconut |
| Stitch Cupcake | 2,140+ | 751 Coins | Milk, Wheat, Butter, Sugarcane, Blueberry |
| Minnie Cupcake | 2,040+ | 745 Coins | Milk, Wheat, Butter, Sugarcane, Apple |
| Princess Aurora Raspberry Cupcake | 1,990+ | 738 Coins | Milk, Wheat, Butter, Sugarcane, Raspberry |
| Mermaid Cupcake | 1,690+ | 785 Coins | Milk, Wheat, Butter, Sugarcane, Scallop |
| Birthday Cake | 2,310+ | 749 Coins | Wheat, Sugarcane, Egg, Butter, Cocoa Bean |
| Aurora’s Cake | 2,030+ | 786 Coins | Raspberry, Wheat, Sugarcane, Egg, Milk |
When I’m cooking these five-star desserts, I usually go for the ones that give me the most energy restoration, since that helps me complete other tasks more efficiently. The Red Velvet is my personal favorite—it restores over 2,400 energy and sells for a decent price too!
My Top Tips for Cooking Efficiently
After spending countless hours in the kitchen (both in-game and real life, let’s be honest), I’ve picked up some strategies that make cooking these fancy desserts much more efficient:
1. Stock Up on Common Ingredients First
I always make sure I have plenty of the basics:
- Wheat: This is used in almost every dessert recipe. I keep a dedicated garden plot just for wheat.
- Sugarcane: Another common ingredient. I grow this in Dazzle Beach where it thrives.
- Eggs: You can buy these from Remy’s pantry once you’ve unlocked him.
- Milk: Also available from Remy’s pantry.
2. Plan Your Ingredient Gathering
When I’m planning a cooking session, I like to gather ingredients by biome:
- Dazzle Beach: Coconuts, sugarcane
- Forest of Valor: Gooseberries, raspberries
- Glade of Trust: Cocoa beans, lemons
- Sunlit Plateau: Cocoa beans, chili peppers
- Frosted Heights: Vanilla, mint
3. Cook in Batches
I’ve found that it’s much more efficient to cook multiple desserts at once rather than one at a time. I usually gather enough ingredients to cook 5-10 desserts in a single session, which helps me complete multiple duties or stock up for future events.
4. Focus on Easy-to-Get Ingredients
Some of my go-to easy recipes include:
- Fruitcake: Just wheat plus any three fruits
- Cheesecake: Cheese, wheat, sugarcane, plus any fruit
- Waffles: Wheat, milk, egg, plus any sweet ingredient
These are great because the “any” ingredients give you flexibility based on what you have available.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
I’ll be honest—I made some mistakes when I first started cooking these fancy desserts. Here’s what I learned so you don’t have to make the same errors:
1. Not Checking Star Ratings
I once spent a bunch of time cooking three-star desserts, wondering why they weren’t counting toward my duty. Always double-check that you’re making four-star or five-star recipes!
2. Forgetting Event-Specific Requirements
Remember that “fairly fancy” can mean different things in different events. Always check the current event requirements rather than assuming they’re the same as last time.
3. Wasting Rare Ingredients
I used my rare ingredients like Vanilla or Cocoa Beans on simple recipes, only to realize I needed them for more complex desserts later. Save your rare ingredients for the five-star recipes that really need them.
FAQ: Your Burning Questions Answered
What’s the easiest fairly fancy dessert to make?
In my experience, the Fruitcake is the easiest because it only requires Wheat plus any three fruits. You can use whatever fruits you have on hand, making it very flexible.
Do I need any expansions to make fairly fancy desserts?
Not necessarily! There are plenty of four-star desserts available in the base game. However, if you have the Eternity Isle or Storybook Vale expansions, you’ll have even more options to choose from.
How many Bubbling Brew Tokens do I get for completing this duty?
You’ll get 20 Bubbling Brew Tokens for cooking three fairly fancy desserts, which is the maximum reward from any single duty in the Witchful Thinking Star Path.
Can I cook the same dessert three times, or do they need to be different?
Great question! You can cook the same dessert three times, and it will still count toward your duty. I often do this when I have a lot of one particular ingredient on hand.
What’s the difference between a fairly fancy dessert and a perfect dessert?
A “fairly fancy dessert” refers to four-star or five-star desserts, while a “perfect dessert” typically means five-star desserts specifically. The terminology can be confusing, but that’s the general distinction.
How long does the Witchful Thinking Star Path last?
The Witchful Thinking Star Path runs from October 1 to December 7, 2026, so you have plenty of time to complete this duty and earn your tokens.
Wrapping It All Up
There you have it—everything you need to know about cooking fairly fancy desserts in Disney Dreamlight Valley! I hope this guide helps you complete that Witchful Thinking Star Path duty with ease and earn those valuable Bubbling Brew Tokens.
Remember, cooking in Dreamlight Valley isn’t just about completing duties—it’s also about having fun and experimenting with different recipes. I’ve discovered some amazing combinations through trial and error, and I encourage you to do the same!
If you found this guide helpful, be sure to bookmark it for future reference, as Star Path events tend to repeat with similar requirements. And don’t forget to check out our other Disney Dreamlight Valley guides for more tips and tricks to make your valley life even more magical.
Happy cooking, and may your kitchen always be filled with delicious desserts and plenty of Bubbling Brew Tokens!
P.S. What’s your favorite dessert to cook in Dreamlight Valley? I’d love to hear about your culinary creations in the comments below!